Keep it good
Chapter review, polish and proofreading
A scored read of the chapter, notes beside the text, and a targeted polish at two levels.
What it is
When a chapter is done, Finish Chapter offers a quality gate in the order an editor works: the review first, while the chapter is still open, then an optional polish, then complete. The chapter review scores your prose across six dimensions — prose quality, pacing, dialogue, sensory detail, character voice, and how human the writing reads rather than machine-generated — then names specific strengths and leaves a short list of editor's notes. Each note says what to change, where it is in the chapter and why it matters to a reader, and is anchored to a real passage that carries the note's number in the text. Polish then works at the level you choose. Line edit fixes named defects only (errors, echoes, filler, stock phrasing and unclear references) and changes just the words that carry them. It never deletes or adds a sentence: the review's notes are yours to act on, from the editor's notes. Proofread fixes spelling, grammar, punctuation and words from the wrong language, and never touches your style. Every change names its reason.
Where to find it: Smart Editor → Finish ▾ → Finish Chapter, or Smart Editor → toolbar → AI tools → Review Chapter. The notes: Smart Editor header → Notes. Proofread on its own: Smart Editor → toolbar → AI tools → Proofread.
What this covers
- Scored review: prose, pacing, dialogue, sensory detail, character voice
- An "AI tells" score for how human the prose reads
- Named strengths, not just faults
- Review first, while the chapter is still open, then polish and complete
- Editor's notes beside the text, numbered in the chapter
- Each note says where it is and why it matters to a reader
- Go to a note's passage without spending credits
- Apply an AI fix, reviewed as a diff
- Fix a repeated problem one place at a time
- Applied suggestions marked done
- Polish at two levels: Line edit or Proofread
- Every change names its reason, shown word by word
- Accept all grammar and language fixes in one click
- Accept or reject each change
- Revision tasks from your own answers
How to use it
- 1
Finish the chapter
From the chapter bar, press Finish Chapter, or use Finish ▾ → Finish Chapter in the Smart Editor. Choose Mark as Complete to finish in one click, Review, then polish to get the editor's notes while the chapter is still open, or Preview as Book. Review, then polish puts a bar above the text with the order: the review, the notes still open, and an optional polish. Complete Chapter on that bar saves your edits and marks the chapter complete, with no second review. After Mark as Complete the chapter is reviewed by itself, and if the text has not changed since the last review the saved one is kept, at no cost. If the chapter already has a review of older text, you are asked first, because a fresh review uses a small amount of credits. The first time you finish a chapter, a short tip explains what each way of finishing does.
- 2
Read the notes
The notes open in a panel beside the text (a sheet from the bottom on a phone) and stay put while you scroll. Each one says what to change, where it is, such as "Scene 2 · ¶ 14", and why it matters to a reader, and its number marks the passage in the text. The six scores fold into one line above them: a signal about where to spend attention, not a grade.
- 3
Go to a note before acting on it
Go to selects and scrolls to the passage without any AI call, so you can judge for yourself whether you agree. When the same problem repeats, the note shows how many more places there are and takes you to each in turn.
- 4
Apply the fixes you agree with
Apply AI fix rewrites just that passage and shows it as a diff. For a problem found in several places, Fix all works one place at a time: the next place is only asked for after you accept or reject the last one, the change you accepted is carried over so the fix stays consistent, and Stop ends it without spending anything more. Accepted fixes are marked done. Dismiss hides a note you disagree with, and it is not offered again for that passage. Apply AI fix works on the whole sentence or paragraph around the quoted words, so a note that asks for something new has room for it. A note about the whole chapter has no AI fix: it is guidance, and how you reshape the chapter is up to you.
- 5
Polish at the level you want
Press Polish on the finishing bar once you have been through the notes, then choose Line edit or Proofread. Nothing is spent until you choose. Line edit fixes errors, echoes, filler, stock phrasing and unclear references, and never deletes or adds a sentence. It leaves the review's notes alone: fix those from the editor's notes, where you see each rewrite before it lands. Proofread fixes only spelling, grammar, punctuation and words from the wrong language, and costs less. Each change shows the words it swaps in red and green, with a chip naming why. Accept all grammar and language fixes takes the objective ones in one click, so you read only the style changes. Undo takes back an Accept or a Reject until you leave the pane. To try both levels, choose Both, one after the other (Proofread first, then a line edit of the corrected text), or press Apply and keep going after one level: it saves what you accepted and takes you back to the finishing bar, with no new review, so you can run the other. Line edit on its own already includes everything Proofread fixes. A change to a sentence Charm Remembers keeps a fact from is marked. Complete Chapter saves the text you accepted and marks the chapter complete. When a level finds nothing to change, the pane says so.
- 6
Proofread on its own
To proofread without finishing the chapter, choose Proofread from the AI tools menu in the toolbar. It fixes spelling, grammar, punctuation and words from the wrong language (calques and missing diacritics included), and Apply fixes saves them without marking the chapter complete. It never runs automatically.
What it gives you
It tells you whether your prose reads as machine-written
The "AI tells" dimension scores how human the writing sounds, naming the specific habits that give generated prose away — while deliberately exempting em-dashes, fragments and anything that is simply your own voice.
Suggestions point at real passages
Every note is verified against the chapter before it is shown, and a numbered marker in the text shows where it is. Go to costs nothing, so you can check the AI understood before you pay for a fix.
Strengths are named too
A review that only lists faults is demoralising and unhelpful. This one tells you what is working, which is what you want to protect while revising.
Proofread is a real proofreader for uk and cs
Ukrainian drafts get checked for russisms and surzhyk, Czech for anglicisms and missing diacritics, along with spelling, grammar and punctuation. It fixes errors only and leaves your writing alone.
Good to know
- The review is one model's opinion of one chapter. Treat low scores as a prompt to look, not as a verdict.
- The "AI tells" score deliberately does not feed the overall score yet — it is a new dimension being measured before it is weighted.
- Line edit changes only paragraphs with a named defect, and only the words that carry it. On a chapter you have tuned by hand, read its style changes one by one rather than accepting them all.
- Proofread never runs by itself, by design. It is your call when to proofread.
- A review is saved per chapter. Asking again about text that has not changed shows the saved review, so you never pay twice for the same read, and Review again in the notes panel always runs a fresh one. Editing the chapter afterwards can make a note stale, and the app says so rather than pointing you at the wrong text.
- Continuity is checked only against what the review is given: the previous chapter's summary and, with Charm Remembers on, the facts you let Charm remember. For contradictions across the whole book, use the Contradictions panel.
Questions
What does the "AI tells" score mean?
It scores how human the prose reads, where five means indistinguishable from a published human author. It looks for the specific habits that mark generated fiction, and explicitly does not penalise em-dashes, sentence fragments or punchy runs, which are ordinary craft.
Does polish change my voice?
Line edit may change a paragraph only for a named defect, never swaps a word for taste, and says why for every change. Proofread does not touch style at all. Every change is a diff you can reject, and the style changes are the ones worth reading.
Do I have to review a chapter to finish it?
No. You can mark a chapter complete without running a review. The review is offered, not enforced.
Why is my Ukrainian review scoring readability oddly?
The readability grade is an English-calibrated formula. In Ukrainian and Czech it is a useful relative signal between your own chapters, not an accurate grade level.
Start your first chapter
Every new account starts with two free credits, enough to talk a whole chapter through, have it drafted, and see how it reads.
Get started free