Keep it good
Consistency and contradictions
Finds where your book disagrees with itself, and proves every flag with a quote.
What it is
CharmWriter checks a book for contradictions in two ways: each chapter against the Story Bible entries it mentions, and chapters against each other wherever they share a character, across the whole book. A flag is shown only when it can quote both passages word for word and a second, more careful reading agrees they cannot both be true. That second reading rejects what is not a contradiction: a detail mentioned in one place and not another, a character changing over time, a figure of speech, a lie told inside the story. Findings collect in the Contradictions hub, grouped into chapters that disagree with each other and Story Bible lines that have fallen behind the book, and each can be resolved by choosing which version is right and reviewing the proposed change before anything is saved.
Where to find it: Workspace → Story Bible panel → Contradictions, at the bottom. If there is no Contradictions panel, switch it on under Settings → General → experience mode — it is off for a new account.
What this covers
- Chapters compared with each other across the whole book
- Chapters checked against the Story Bible
- Every flag quotes both passages
- A second, careful reading before anything is shown
- Grouped by what the flag means
- Stale Story Bible lines fixed in the Bible, not your book
- Jump to the source of a fact
- AI-proposed fixes reviewed as diffs
- Dismiss with a reason and undo
- Cleared automatically, with Restore
- Rescans of unchanged chapters are free
- Consistency Check in the chapter editor
- Contradiction rings on the Story Map
How to use it
- 1
Open the Contradictions hub
It sits at the bottom of the Story Bible panel. Open flags are grouped into Your chapters disagree and Story Bible is out of date.
- 2
Run a scan
Scan All reads every chapter against the Story Bible and compares chapters that share characters. Chapters you have not changed since the last scan are skipped and cost nothing. When it finishes, it tells you how many possible conflicts it checked and how many held up.
- 3
Check both passages
Every flag quotes the two passages that disagree and names where each came from. Click a source to jump to that chapter or Story Bible entry.
- 4
Decide which version is right
When a chapter and the Story Bible disagree, keeping the chapter is the default, because the chapter is your text, so the fix updates the Bible. You can choose the Bible version instead, or write your own.
- 5
Review the fix
A change to the Story Bible is shown as a diff to accept or reject. A change to a chapter opens in the Smart Editor as a proposal. Nothing in your book changes until you accept it. Accepting the change in the Smart Editor marks the contradiction resolved. If the passage has already changed, the note in the editor offers Mark as resolved instead.
- 6
Dismiss what is intentional
An unreliable narrator is not a continuity error. Dismiss a flag with a reason and it stays dismissed, however the next scan words it. You get an undo window, and a whole group can be dismissed at once.
- 7
See what was cleared automatically
Flags that did not hold up are listed under Cleared automatically, each with its reason. Nothing is deleted: Restore brings a flag back, and a flag you restore is never cleared again.
What it gives you
Quiet by default
A flag has to quote both passages and survive a second reading. Most chapters get no flags at all, and the ones you do see are worth reading.
It catches the errors that are invisible up close
Nobody remembers in chapter nineteen that the boiler was orange in chapter one. Comparing chapters across the whole book is exactly the work a continuity editor charges for.
Your book is the reference
When a chapter and the Story Bible disagree, the chapter wins by default and the Bible is corrected. Your prose changes only when you choose that and accept the edit.
The writing AI works from verified facts
Only verified flags reach the AI that drafts with you, so it is never steered by a conflict that does not exist.
Good to know
- A scan reads whole chapters, so on a long book it costs accordingly. Rescanning chapters you have not changed is free.
- It finds factual disagreement, not plot holes. "This character would never do that" is a judgement it cannot make.
- It prefers silence to noise, so a real inconsistency can occasionally go unflagged. Each Scan All compares up to twelve chapter pairs it has not read yet, neighbours first, so a long book is covered over several scans.
- Charm's own notes in the Story Bible (the per-section notes and the arc log) are not compared, because they are written from your chapters.
Questions
How is this different from the chapter review?
The review judges quality: prose, pacing, dialogue. Contradiction checking judges facts: whether your book agrees with itself. They answer different questions.
Does it check automatically?
After you save a chapter in the Smart Editor, that chapter is checked against the Story Bible. The Consistency Check button in the editor checks the chapter on demand. The whole-book Scan All is manual.
My character contradicts herself on purpose. Will it keep flagging that?
Usually not: a lie or a mistaken belief inside the story is not treated as a contradiction. If one is flagged, dismiss it with a reason and it stays dismissed.
Where did my old contradictions go?
Flags from before this version were checked again. The ones that could not quote your book, or only compared two Story Bible notes, are under Cleared automatically with the reason. Restore brings any of them back.
Where else do contradictions show up?
On the Story Map, any entity with an unresolved contradiction wears a red ring, and the Conflict lens shows only those entities.
Start your first chapter
Every new account starts with two free credits, enough to talk a whole chapter through, have it drafted, and see how it reads.
Get started free